Question detail
A substance has a melting point of 100°C and a boiling point of 150°C. If a sample of this substance melts at 98°C and boils at 148°C, is the substance pure or impure? Justify your answer.
Try the question, check the answer, then read the explanation to understand the curriculum point.
At a glance
Question
Type
exam_style
Style
Topic
Purity, formulations and chromatography
Question
A substance has a melting point of 100°C and a boiling point of 150°C. If a sample of this substance melts at 98°C and boils at 148°C, is the substance pure or impure? Justify your answer.
Answer
A high-scoring answer should explain interpret melting point or boiling point data to decide whether a substance is pure or impure. Use method first, observation second, conclusion last: name the relevant test or measurement, state the observation, and then connect the result to Pure substances.
Explanation
This is correct because single element or compound / fixed melting point is the evidence expected for pure substance, and purity evidence is the result that supports the conclusion. A complete answer should use the approved objective wording, include the relevant evidence, and avoid unsupported identification claims.
Common mistake
Identifying Purity from Melting Points
Students often think that a substance is pure if it has a melting point that matches the literature value, without considering the possibility of impurities affecting the melting point.
Students should remember that impurities can lower or raise the melting point, and they should analyze the melting point range to determine purity.
Related flashcards
Flashcard 1 of 5
Related practice questions
Question 1 of 5
Choose an answer, get feedback, then move sideways through the set.
