Question detail
During a comparison of experimental and theoretical lattice enthalpies for MgO, the experimental value is 1800 kJ mol⁻¹ and the theoretical value is 1700 kJ mol⁻¹. What does this discrepancy suggest about the covalent character of the MgO bond, and how would you justify your conclusion using lattice enthalpy concepts?
Try the question, check the answer, then read the explanation to understand the curriculum point.
At a glance
Question
Type
exam_style
Style
Topic
Thermodynamics (A-level only)
Question
During a comparison of experimental and theoretical lattice enthalpies for MgO, the experimental value is 1800 kJ mol⁻¹ and the theoretical value is 1700 kJ mol⁻¹. What does this discrepancy suggest about the covalent character of the MgO bond, and how would you justify your conclusion using lattice enthalpy concepts?
Answer
A lower theoretical lattice enthalpy than the experimental value indicates that the real crystal releases more energy than predicted by the ideal point‑charge model. This excess energy release suggests that the MgO bond has a greater covalent character than assumed in the theoretical calculation, which treats the ions as purely ionic. The stronger covalent interaction increases the lattice energy beyond the purely ionic estimate, leading to the experimental value being higher.
Explanation
The answer defines both experimental and theoretical lattice enthalpies, identifies the key difference (experimental > theoretical), explains when each applies (real crystal vs idealised model), and concludes that the discrepancy indicates increased covalent character. This assesses the student’s ability to interpret lattice enthalpy data in terms of bond character.
Common mistake
Confusing Experimental and Theoretical Lattice Enthalpies
Students often confuse experimental lattice enthalpy with theoretical lattice enthalpy, thinking they are the same concept.
Experimental lattice enthalpy is determined through measurements, while theoretical lattice enthalpy is calculated using models based on ionic charges and sizes. To avoid confusion, remember that experimental values are obtained from real-world data, whereas theoretical values are predictions based on assumptions. Use experimental data when available to validate theoretical predictions.
Related flashcards
Flashcard 1 of 5
Related practice questions
Question 1 of 5
Choose an answer, get feedback, then move sideways through the set.
